Please help me choose: Jupiter JTS500Q vs Yamaha YTS280

pepitogrillado

Fresh Member
Hello everyone!

I am an adult pianist. In music school, I also took flute lessons as a secondary instrument - which I enjoyed a lot, in fact from time to time I still play it. A couple of weeks ago I started tenor sax classes, and I am liking it a lot!

I am currently using a friend's Yamaha (I believe it is a 280). However, it is old and has been unused for a lot a lot of time. I find it really difficult to hit the E, D and C low octave notes, and the higher octave sounds a bit out of tune. Looks like it probably needs adjustments as well as pad replacements - which I am not looking to pay for given it's not my instrument.

I went to a music store to try different options on the €1000 range. Out of what I played, I am in between Jupiter JTS500Q and Yamah YTS280. I have considered the following thoughts, and I was wondering if you would be able to help me weight/furhter inform them?

[ul]
[li]The Jupiter wins in tone: I felt it was rich, warm, dark and full, which is what I am looking for. Meanwhile, I feel the sound of the Yamaha it's a bit more bright and metallic (although I like it too!). The store staff said this is due to the metal of the Yamaha is a bit more thin. I played both with my Selmer C* mouthpiece, and I believe that changing the mouthpiece really can modify the tone of the sound. So basically I guess I could also get a more warm/dark/fuller sound with the Yamaha in the future, by changing the mouthpiece?[/li]
[/ul]
[ul]
[li]The Jupiter was easier to play - I just was able to get better sound and more dynamics with low effort in blowing[/li]
[/ul]
[ul]
[li]The Jupiter also wins in price - €940 vs €1340[/li]
[/ul]
On the other hand:
[ul]
[li]Yamaha 280 has a lot of good reviews online suggesting more durability, while Jupiter has some bad publicity (particularly for older models). What do you think?[/li]
[/ul]
[ul]
[li]Yamaha seems to be a beginner/intermediate instrument, while Jupiter is labelled as beginner "only". I am presuming the Yamaha offers more flexibility and more room to grow on sax, being able to play with more dynamics in sound. To what extent do you think this is right?[/li]
[/ul]
[ul]
[/ul] [li]The Yamaha feels a bit (just a bit) lighter and seems to have a better case (but these are not decisive factors to me..)[/li]

Thanks a lot for your help, really appreciate it!!
 
Última edición:

Totti

Fresh Member
Hi Pepitogrillado, as a general piece of advice most of the followers in this forum would go for the Yamaha. It’s a very well-known and respected brand in comparison with the other one. However as you say you feel better with the Jupiter in your hands it sometimes changes everything. Another aspect to take into consideration would be if at some point in the future you want to upgrade it, Yamaha’s normally keep a good “reselling” value... at least higher than Jupiter’s. Don’t worry about those notes you don’t get to play right now, the more you practice the better, in no time they will come out easily.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Arriba